Lot No. 40 Cask Strength 2017 Release
Long Awaited Cask Strength Canadian Rye
10 489
Review by @Victor
- Nose~
- Taste~
- Finish~
- Balance~
- Overall89
Show rating data charts
Distribution of ratings for this:
- Brand: Lot No. 40
- Type: Canadian
- ABV: 55%
- Batch: 2017
My deep thanks to @paddockjudge for the reviewed sample. The 2017 release of Lot 40 Cask Strength was aged 12 years. This batch of Lot 40 is reported to be made from 100% unmalted rye grain and added commercial enzymes
Nose: clear, clean, crisp, strong high-middle-pitched rye spice flavours dominate. There is a hint of some nice dark fruit in the background, along with a very light floral note. Flavours from wood including vanilla and light caramel also remain mostly in the background. This is strong and attractive, while showing little development or subtlety. A gentle sweetness only partially balances the spiciness. Water added raised the pitch while lowering complexity, bundled the flavours, and increased sweetness. This is better without water. Score: 23/25 points neat; 20.5/25 points with water added
Taste: Big aggressive spicy rye dominates, as in the nose. There are just hints of dark fruit to accompany the spice. The spice flavours are intense, clean, and appealing, but with little sweet balance. Water brings out black licorice and increases sweetness. Better without water. Score: 22.5/25 neat; 21/25 with water added
Finish: strong flavours which last quite long. Lot 40 CS is spice, spice, and more spice. Some bitterness from wood and/or the rye grain used takes control by the death. With water added complexity is lost in a bundled package of flavours. Score: 22/25 neat; 20/25 with water
Balance: very good balance in the nose, good on the delivery, fair by the death. Sweet balance is lacking. 2017 Lot 40 Cask Strength is a spice trip without the rich fruitiness of the standard younger Lot 40 or an adequate sweet balance. Score: 21/25 neat; 20/25 with water added
Total Sequential Score: 88.5 points neat; 81.5 points with water added
.......................
Strength: strong in the nose; very strong thereafter. Score: 23.5/25 points
Quality: the rye spices are excellent; the wood flavours are only adequate. Score: 22.5/25 points
Variety: very adequate variety, but more fruit would greatly elevate this whisky. Score: 21.5/25 points
Harmony: very good in the nose, good on delivery, fair at the death. More sweet balance would elevate this whisky. Score: 21.5/25 points
Total Non-Sequential Score: 89 points
........................
Comment: 6 or 7 years ago I asked for a Cask Strength version of Lot 40 and waited. This older brother of the standard Lot 40 is only loosely identifiable as being in the same extended family
2017 Lot 40 Cask Stength is powerful and flavourful, but not elegant. If you can enjoy that then you can greatly enjoy Lot 40 CS. Compared to the standard Lot 40 this is a turbo-charged spice attack to the detriment of the fruitiness, which is what I like best about standard Lot 40
Is this 2017 Lot 40 Cask Strength all that I had for 5 years hoped that it would be? No, but it is quite enjoyable. I think that bottling at Cask Strength reveals the full astringency of rye grain whisky absent textural buffering from corn. Some will find that effect abrupt, others harsh
It's hard to believe you are reviewing the same whisky I reviewed (I reviewed it twice - once from notes at SOT and once almost a year ago from the bottle).
It's not that we disagree on the quality, but I think we tasted very different things in it.
Based on your review, I wonder if you would enjoy this year's release a little more. I certainly can't wait to find out.