Eagle Rare 10 Year old

A Solid House Bourbon

Reviewed by
Connosr member:

MuddyFunster

Date:

13th Nov 2015

Reviewer rating:

85

About this score:

  • Nose: 23
  • Taste: 21
  • Finish: 20
  • Balance: 21

The average score for this whisky is 82.

Best price to buy online:

Tasting Notes by MuddyFunster

I got very excited when I saw Eagle Rare 10 in Waitrose (upmarket UK supermarket) for a really good price (£36). Beautiful looking bottle design and I'm already a fan of Buffalo Trace, so had to try this.

This bottle has been open a while now (6 months) and there's about a third left. Whilst it has never really blown me away, it's a solid little number for the price.

So I believe this used to be Single Barrel and kind of probably is, as they are still bottled barrel by barrel. It's just that the bottling process means this is not 100% guaranteed now as you might get a bottle between two barrels, so they don't say it on the label. Think the Mashbill is Buffalo Trace #1 which is said to be 8% rye. same mashbill as the standard BT bottling. Just aged for 10.

Colour is clear light brown, oily in the glass. Nice looking Bourbon.

Nose: nicest thing about this. First the caramels and muscovado sugars, some nice strong grape and dessert wine vinous notes, there's some spice coming through but it's at the back, hints of orange and red fruit, definitely cranberry, maybe cherry, maybe strawberry, but it's hidden away. Second nose and the woods prominent. Quite fresh and clean oak, touch of vanilla.

Taste: At the front I'm getting that grapey, sweet wine vinous texture, brown sugars and caramels, spices coming through nicely, maybe a little bit of red berry fruit. Touch of cherry or cranberry. Wood character is there, fresh oak wood, touch of vanilla.

Finish is not huge. A little disappointing. Caramel and brown sugars, little spice.

A nice solid house bourbon but not reaching to greater heights, nowhere near the antique collection.

Tags

Whisky details

Distillery/Brand:

Eagle Rare

Colour:

Old Sauternes

Comments

Pete1969

Pete1969 wrote:

Looking at your reviews you like Buffalo Trace as do I and big flavours Stagg and VW neither of which I have been able to find at a price I would pay. You might find the Blanton's line up suits your tastes as Buffalo trace juice but ramped up a notch, the original is solid but the SFTB uncut and unfiltered at around 65abv is a pure joy when it has been allowed a bit of time to oxidise.

I have a bottle of the Eagle Rare bunkered 2 weeks ago and will be getting to it sooner rather than later after your review.

14 November 2015 01:07
MuddyFunster

MuddyFunster wrote:

Thanks Pete. Yes I do really like Blantons. I have the Gold unopened but tried it and loved it in bars. Had the original single barrel last weekend in a bar and it was very good. Haven't had the SFTB but been mulling buying one.

14 November 2015 17:58

Add a comment

You must be logged in to comment if you don't have an account why not sign up?

Whisky reviews by distiller (A - D)