Talisker 10 Year old

the perfect development

Reviewed by
Connosr member:



3rd Dec 2014

Reviewer rating:


About this score:

  • Nose: 22
  • Taste: 23
  • Finish: 21
  • Balance: 24

The average score for this whisky is 85.

Best price to buy online:

Tasting Notes by fishy1oh

as i write this review i am sipping on the 6th glass talisker in the past 2 weeks. the more time i spend with the whisky the more i realise how perfect the balance of honey and pepper is, and how well they work together to compliment the smoky, salty ocean aromas that make talisker unique. at such a young age this whisky has remarkable complexity and a sublime arrival. one pleasing thing i found about talisker 10 is that there is almost no alcohol burn at all and the phenolic nose is easily subdued with the addition of a few drops of water and a few minutes in a covered glass.

on the nose it is; salty, smoky ocean air almost like a beach bonfire with damp wood. hints of peat and smoked oysters, water helps it open up to reveal a thick sweetness that perfectly fuses with the oceanic tang. there is a thick honey aroma that slowly reveals itself over time and gets stronger as the smoke subsides.

the initial taste is sweet honey and flower pollen,it is quite warming and makes a perfect winter dram. this sweetness subtlety evolves into a creamy, peppery, light spice with a strong salty brine smoky flavour. the balance between these flavours is magnificent and the development is quite amazing. for such a young whisky i find the maturity to be outstanding - and although the youngness can be detected on the nose and in the finish, it hardly takes away from the overall experience.

the finish is long and drawn out and is reminiscent of the initial nose - salty, brine, smoked oysters and peat. there is a very slight phenolic, alcoholic taste but if anything it adds to the character of the whisky and like most islay's (yes i know its not actually an islay) it bennefits from a slight immaturity, at least in my opinion it helps add a bit of extra flare.

the body of this whisky is slightly oily at first but the finish leaves the mouth dry almost the way sea water does.

some minnor bad points about this drink are that there is e150 caramel added and it is chill filtered and at least for my taste i find the fishy? brine nose to be a little off putting but i can in no way subtract any point for that because the balance of honey more than compensates.

as a side note, i think this whisky (although bottled at 45.8%) benefits from only a small amount of water, less than 4 drops and definitely opens up well in a covered glass. i am personally very pleased with my first encounter with talisker and definitely recommend trying the 10 yr old.


Whisky details








Pale Gold



Georgy wrote:

I totally agree with you there!

22 October 2016 11:27

Pete1969 wrote:

Another accessible entry level malt, give me a lifetime supply of Talisker 10, OP12, HP12, Laphroiag 10 or QC and Arberlour 10 or 12 and I would be happy. All the aforementioned are less than £30 when on offer. Chuck in a decent bourbon in the same range WT101 or Beam Black and I am edging towards heaven.

I am as guilty as the next of wanting the next level drink, but as a regular cabinet would you really need to look outside that list, unless you really have to put in a rye (WT is rye forward). Regularly changing which bottle you drink should prevent boredom, plus birthdays and Xmas give the chance for specials.

Now I only need to listen to my own advice and stop buying all the other stuff just because I want to try it.

22 October 2016 21:08

Georgy wrote:

@Pete1969 I perfectly agree. Sometimes it's better to stick to the guys who make you happy no matter what:)

23 October 2016 08:35

Add a comment

You must be logged in to comment if you don't have an account why not sign up?

Whisky reviews by distiller (A - D)