I am a small time investor in whisky. I buy what I think might sell well in the future.
About 6 months ago I bought a few of the batch 5, then going through an airport I saw batch 4 hidden away in dark corner and snapped up the last three of them. Then I hunted around and found a few more still available of batch 2, I still hadn't tried even a dram of this stuff at this time, but I saw a lot of internet chatter about Tun 1401.
For some reason I thought, what the hell, let's complete the collection. I then paid a stupid amount for a bottle of batch 1 (about £1000/$1500) from scotchwhiskyauctions.com. I got two bottles of batch 3 imported from the US for retail price (Yeeha!)
It got to a stage where I had the best part of 15 or 20 bottles of a whisky I had never even tasted. I figured, well, if it all appreciates by even 10% I can afford to drink a bottle or two and lose nothing.
Well, I cracked open a bottle of batch 2 (I had three of them and knew where I could get two more for a decent price). NECTAR!
Such a rich, woody, complex, sweet nose and deep amber colour. Even through the initial alcohol fumes, but after letting the glass sit for 15 minutes the nose just developed constantly.
If you leave the glass to sit for a few hours the smell of a bowl of prunes and figs with a hint of sweet bonfire smoke. Damn, it's mesmerising.
Then, I had to open a bottle from another batch to compare. Batch 5, very comparable but softer flavours and nose, but perhaps more complex and lighter at the same time.
At the time of writing this review batch 6 has just been launched a week ago and I had my bottles of it arrive this morning.
My intention has now changed. I am keeping one bottle of each batch as an investment. A fully intact range of every single batch released. However, every single other Tun 1401 I own has now migrated to my "I REALLY need to drink this" collection rather than my "do not touch my investment" collection. Aside from Karuizawa Noh bottlings, this is the only time I have ever gone against my original intentions and turning an investment into something I cannot resist myself.
I would be hard pushed to state which expression, but I can tell you, Tun 1401 is in my top 5 whisky drinking experiences and I really recommend you crack open that bottle you have tucked away and drink it.
I believe Clynelish is Brora. I may be mistaken. Value goes up for a number of reasons - the particular expression came in a nice box, it was limited to a few hundred bottles, it was the oldest, etc. It's always worth looking for a unique characteristic in addition to the reputation of the distillery. Also, basic economics - scarcity breeds value. Snow Phoenix, for example, is a limited edition of about 6.9 billion bottles. It's not very scarce. Whereas some of the 60 and 70 year olds, very scarce. If something tastes good and is scarce it will go up in value.
Hi Kian. Whisky is one of the best investments in the global market today for any kind of investment level. I used to be a market analyst and have not seen annual growth rates approaching this with such stability anywhere else. Of course, things can go up and down, but even if the recession leads into another boom cycle it should just increase the demand for luxury goods. So, for luxury commodities to do so well during a downturn is excellent.
The global whisky market is growing as a whole, yet the amount of truly old, aged single malts is limited and dwindling in relative terms. I actually wrote an algorithm that factors in a variety of attributes: number of initial bottles, time in barrel, metascore from reviewers, popularity of distillery, how active the distillery is, etc. Then I tracked this back against historical data from auction sites and it was pretty close. The algorithm projects very healthy returns.
And yes, people always want to return to the source, they want the earliest examples of what they have come to love and what made a range popular.
Also, certain releases of Tun 1401 are harder to obtain depending on where you are in the world. However, like any investment, I would never advocate drawing all your bottles from one keg (or tun in this case). Diversification is key, but when you know that something is good it's not a bad idea to go into it hard for a time. For me, at the moment, Karuizawa, Brora, Tun 1401 and a few others are good investments right now.
I have not been selling. I am still in the acquisition stage. In total I do not have a lot of bottles, but the average bottle is worth a fair bit.
I expect, even if things don't perform very well, to have more than tripled my money within a decade with minimal risk.
For example, I have some bottles of 42 year old Karuizawa 1967. This is one of the oldest whiskies produced by Japan, with amazingly high scores by every critic that tried it, less than 200 bottles left in the world, the distillery has been obliterated off the face of the Earth. A year ago you could buy this drink for about £500 a bottle, now I reckon it's over £2000 and probably, within a decade those bottles could go for anything up to £10k if the market holds out.
You need to know what you're buying, but if you make a bad mistake or two you can always drink it or give it away as a nice gift or swap it with someone for something else.