Whisky Connosr
Menu
Shop Join

James E. Pepper 1776 Straight Rye 15yr

Happy Birthday America

2 692

@newreverieReview by @newreverie

5th Jul 2017

1

  • Nose
    ~
  • Taste
    ~
  • Finish
    ~
  • Balance
    ~
  • Overall
    92

Show rating data charts

Distribution of ratings for this: user

  • Brand: James E. Pepper
  • ABV: 45.65%

I haven't had many James E Pepper offerings. There is a barrel proof non age stated rye and a few different bourbons available, but today is a special day.

The 1776 brand has a complex story written on the bottle. I don't know what the correct ratio of truth to marketing is, but i what i do know is that this is 15 year Indiana rye bottled from hand selected barrels to match an "old style" flavor. The rye content is at least 90% and this was bottled at barrel proof without chill filtering. Also Mr. Pepper was a Colonel, so he outranks Sgt. Pepper (take that imperialist Britain!).

I opened this bottle at my lake house last year. Others seemed to have found it and it is now about 1/3 full (yes Americans are optimists on our holiday).

Color is a dark rose gold, definitely aged in charred oak.

Nose: Wonderful rye character is immediate. Cherry, orange, and leather swap positions. I give my glass a swirl and ponder on the Kentucky derby. Lovely white pepper and dill pull ahead while oak stays in the middle of the pack. Light floral rose and jasmine surge for a moment and then fade. A few minutes have passed and i have yet to take a sip. Banana and caramel comingled with more rye. The nose continues to sweeten as time passes, but it is always strong and full of character.

Taste: God bless America. This is good. The style matches somewhere between the willet and pikesville rye. It is on the sweeter side including honey, liquorice, and cereal, but still has plenty of pepper and spice. The wood provides an excellent base for all of the flavors and ties everything together.

Finish: Warming and spicy, but no burn. Rye is here, but fruit dominates. Orange peel without the bitterness. Pineapple rind. Big red gum. The flavors fade into candied rye.

Balance: Excellent throughout and one of the best ryes I've ever had. I am usually happy with one glass of any whisky, but this one begs for another.

6 comments

@newreverie
newreverie commented

I sent this review to my dad. It turns out he has had the lions share of this bottle and has been searching for more ever since he first tried it. Sadly it is one of those unicorn bottles that can never be replaced. I told him next time to drink something we can get more of like the pappy 23. Or if he must have a unicorn rye, there is a perfectly good whistle pig 15yr here. connosr.com/whistlepig-15-year-old-whisky-…

about one year ago 1Who liked this?

@Robert99
Robert99 commented

@newreverie I love the effect of air and time on rye and virgin oak whiskies. I find it's contribute to the floral notes and the banana flavor (big time). How was this bottle on opening?

about one year ago 0

@newreverie
newreverie commented

@Robert99 it is hard for me to remember that long ago, but I think it was a bit more woody. I might have scored it 2 points lower as a fresh bottle. I have one more unoppened here at the house but it will probably be years before I open it.

about one year ago 0

@MadSingleMalt
MadSingleMalt commented

"I don't know what the correct ratio of truth to marketing is"—the slogan for us all in the 21st-century whisky market!

about one year ago 0

@Robert99
Robert99 commented

@newreverie Thanks for the prompt answer. I will be looking for it in the future.

about one year ago 0

@newreverie
newreverie commented

@Robert99 I ended up opening my second bottle of this. Stunning. This continues to be the best rye I have ever had.

9 months ago 0

You must be signed-in to comment here

Sign in