Whisky Connosr
Menu
Shop Join

Ardbeg Supernova

A bit of a gimmick this I'm afraid.

0 640

@JohnoftheYardReview by @JohnoftheYard

30th Aug 2009

0

  • Nose
    ~
  • Taste
    ~
  • Finish
    ~
  • Balance
    ~
  • Overall
    40

Show rating data charts

Distribution of ratings for this: brand user

I'm a fan of Ardbeg and I've tasted most of the range that is generally available and like to think I know a little bit about whisky and so I know this review may seem a bit controversial.

On the nose I'm totally blown away by the spirit with a huge hit of smoke and a feeling that someone has just stuck a handful of crushed black pepper up my nose, not a pleasant experience.

The first sip of any high strength whisky can take your breath away and this was no different, massive hits of smoke, black pepper and a nasty taste of dried chilli flakes.

With water nothing really changes, I added 25% then 50% and cleared my pallet but nothing could improve the flavour I'm afraid to say.

Sadly I feel this is a bit of a "look as what we can do" drink a sort of vindaloo for whisky and whilst I no doubt will receive some criticism and possibly some questions as to my gender I feel the harsh tone is justified as I don't think there is any excuse for this kind of nonsense, by all means make peaty drinks but not so overpowering as to render your senses dead in the water.

Related Ardbeg reviews

6 comments

@Anonymous
Anonymous commented

An honest review - sounds like Ardbeg have missed the mark this time

10 years ago 0

@JohnoftheYard
JohnoftheYard commented

I think they have, just too overpowering ruining any of the subtle notes and flavours.

10 years ago 0

@MuddyVitae
MuddyVitae commented

I have to agree with you. This isn't a whiskey you savor, it's a curiosity that you unravel. While I'm amazed by the pyrotechnical display of flavors (dry erase marker, peppers, endless peat, barbecue sauce, I could go on), it doesn't really amount to a sipping drink. It's a good bottle to talk about, and maybe everyone should try it once, but I would never buy it again or order it in a bar.

10 years ago 0

@cartermclean
cartermclean commented

Would have to disagree here. Supernova is in my top 5. ITs a great dram!!! If your not into peat yes this is NOT your thing but I love the intensity and the finish lasts for days!!!! It opens up about 25 30 mins and the nose is great. To each their own. Cheers!

9 years ago 0

paulrpotts commented

I don't think I'd rate it as low as you did, but having tasted the 2009 Supernova a few times now I partly agree. The huge peat and ABV do tend to numb the tongue and palate, and I think there is a tendency for some of the more delicate notes to be overwhelmed. I think I like the Rollercoaster a little more. Both are very young whiskies and I'm starting to think I like my Ardbeg to smooth out a little bit more.

9 years ago 0

@mster
mster commented

Hi john, since you have had tasted a wide range of ardbeg's other expression, which would you say are your favorites? And why. Just a curios question. Ta.

8 years ago 0

You must be signed-in to comment here

Sign in