Whisky Connosr
Shop Join

Edradour 1997 11 Year Old Chateau Neuf Du Pape Finish

Sour lining

0 367

@markjedi1Review by @markjedi1

6th Sep 2010


  • Nose
  • Taste
  • Finish
  • Balance
  • Overall

Show rating data charts

Distribution of ratings for this: brand user

Edradour is known for its finishes, bottles in the series ‘Straight from the Cask’, meaning this is single cask whisky at cask strength. This one is a challenging 57,2%, 12 years old and received a maturation in a hogshead for 10 years, before being re-racked for 18 monhts in a Châteauneuf-du-Pape wine cask.

Châteauneuf-du-Pape, which means ‘the new castle of the pope’, is a famous village annex castle in the wine region of the Rhône. The wine is produced from a whole range of grapes. The most important ones are the Grenache Noir, Syrah and Cinsaut (red wijn), Grenach Blanc, Clairette Rose and Roussanne (white and rosé wine).

The wine is very prominent on the nose, insofar that you have to look for the whisky (the same happened with the Sauternes finish). And after a minute or two, I get some ‘dirty’, organic notes (cooked vegetables?), that are a bit off-putting. Adding a bit of water merely gives the nose a sour lining, something a little burned.

It’s less fierce than initially expected at 57,2%, and immediately turns wondrously sweet. I get some dark fruits such as raisins and maybe even figs. After the somewhat off-putting nose, this is a welcome change. The addition of water turns it a little bit sour. Different, sure, but not very nice.

The finish last very long, is nicely spiced, but drying and a little bitter, like the peels of chestnuts. Very oaky.

Again, the taste needs to make up for the nose, but barely succeeds.

Related Edradour reviews


markjedi1 commented

Please note that I had the 12 year old (and not the depicted 11 year old).

10 years ago 0

OJK commented

@markjedi1: Nice review - I've tried some of the wine finishes from Edradour and have to say I'm not yet won over. They should be applauded for trying new things but I agree there's a somewhat off-putting overly dominant wine presence on the nose, making it seem a bit like Ribena (or Cassis in france) very much past its sell-by date!

10 years ago 0

Nemesis101 commented

I know I'm commenting on a three year old review here but I've just tried the 2002 vintage of this, (11yo) and it sounds a world away from this one. Very intriguing how much difference a few years can make, (either that or we have completely different taste buds).

7 years ago 0

You must be signed-in to comment here

Sign in