Whisky Connosr
Shop Join

Glenrothes 1998 vintage

Spicy Honey; Quite Spirited.

0 276

@jwiseReview by @jwise

15th Jan 2011


  • Nose
  • Taste
  • Finish
  • Balance
  • Overall

Show rating data charts

Distribution of ratings for this: brand user

This is the newest of the Glenrothes vintages. It is a 10 yrs and 2 mos. old. This is the youngest official bottling that I know of from The Glenrothes, so I was a bit curious about it. It is the first of the vintages that the distillery bottled that was expressly laid down at its origin to be bottled as Glenrothes on maturity, and therefore there is a greater availability of stock than any of the previous bottlings.

This is also Gordon Motion’s first bottling as Malt Master of The Glenrothes, and he describes it as: “It’s said that pictures speak a thousand words and this is like Carmen Miranda’s hat in a bottle. Tropical fruits lead with pineapple and mango developing into sweet bananas, coconut and classic Glenrothes vanilla pods.”

So, it is understandable that this bottle has a bit of "proving" to do.

Nose: Fresh cut grass, lots of nose tingle, very acidic. Not really liking this one. Ouch! Ok, pineapple, in that it is sweet, but tangy sweet. Ginger spice. Immature, malty, very spirity. This is an "active" whisky, and in need of a good time-out. Coming back I'm getting some banana malt.

Body: Light, but not watery.

Palate: Sweet and tangy, with spice on the tongue. Spicy honey?

Finish: Not especially smooth. Medium in length, releasing a nice amount of spice and ripe fruit.

I am disappointed. I had high hopes for this whisky, and special ordered two bottles (one to drink, one to lay up). I am hoping this bottle calms down a bit once it has been opened. Some bottles can improve with a little aeration, and I am hoping this is one of them.

I will be trying this one off and on at different times and circumstances, to see if it can improve somehow. I am just not a big fan of spirited, young whiskies. The depth is missing, only hitting the high notes (if that makes any sense). Where is the toffee? Where is the butterscotch? What happened to the creamy vanilla that The Glenrothes is so known for? Its not here, and that's for sure. I had purposefully avoided the '94, as I was led to believe that bottle had this flavor profile. Now I'm wondering if they got the labels switched, and the '94 is the good one?

This whisky is lightyears away from the '92 or especially the '91. There's an edge to this whisky that is...harsh? Yes. Harsh. It needs about five more years in the cask, I think.

Related Glenrothes reviews


jwise commented

Correction: The whisky is 12yrs old. I was looking at the "approved date" instead of "bottled in" date.

12 years ago 0

jwise commented

I've sampled this whisky a couple times since writing this review, and am actually drinking it again tonight with some crackers, cheese, and some milk chocolate squares. It isn't winning any awards, but it is enjoyable in this combination.

12 years ago 0

You must be signed-in to comment here

Sign in