Whisky Connosr
Menu
Shop Join

Knob Creek 9 Year Old

Knob where art thou?

0 379

mReview by @masterj

3rd Dec 2012

0

Knob Creek 9 Year Old
  • Nose
    ~
  • Taste
    ~
  • Finish
    ~
  • Balance
    ~
  • Overall
    79

Show rating data charts

Distribution of ratings for this: brand user

Knob Creek was among the first Bourbons I tasted and years later it seems slightly more tamed than my first encounter with it. It doesn't quite pack the same wallop as I remember it having.

Nose: Classic bourbon nose. Molasses, fresh cut sugar cane, brown sugar,syrup, charred oak. This nose has a slight hint of flour as well along with fresh oak,all spice, and resin. Just by the smell you know your going to be drinking a dense and perhaps, challenging Whiskey. I'm up for the challenge! are you?

Palate: Immediately oaky. Rich, intense, full mouth feel but this intensity passed rather quickly. It starts slightly peppery which deceives you into thinking it's setting you up for a wallop and then the charred oak returns once the pepper settles down which is rather quickly and..... nothing. Tastes like your sucking on freshly cut sugar cane. But it's not the palate I expected. It punches lighter, below the weight ingrained in my memory...sigh.

Finish: Rather short to medium. Earthy notes. More charred oak. Some all spice and pine resin. Creamy, slightly vanilla oak notes as well along with some waxy honey comb.

But what of that wallop Whiskey that offered a challenge in my first battle with a bourbon? What of that bruiser that was for me, knob creek?! I just don't know what has happened. This Whiskey seems far from the beast I remember. Maybe it's the quality of this particular batch that's gone down but this knob is just not the same Whiskey I remember. It could also be that now, years later, I have a more discerning palate. But to me, it's less peppery, it's less rich, and just average now. It's palatable now, which makes it decent, but that's all Knob Creek is for me. Whiskey's with less ABV have a much better oomph! than this here Knob. Quite disappointing based on my previous memories. It's still decent though but no longer is it something memorable.

Related Knob Creek reviews

3 comments

masterj commented

Spartan reviewed Knob Creek before me and he seems to be describing the exact Knob Creek I tasted 2-3yrs ago! I wish that Whiskey was in my glass tonight instead of this sub-par Knob.

11 years ago 0

@MyLoSyRo
MyLoSyRo commented

(Disclaimer: I'm new to the forum and relatively new to the bourbon scene so apologies in advance if my submission seems sophomoric) I am disappointed that Knob Creek has moved away from a cork and to a screw top. For me, it takes away from the "ritual" of the pour. I salivate at the pop of the cork and the subsequent rush of liquid over some ice...yes, sorry to offend the purists but I like all drinks chilled and that includes my bourbon....so shoot me. That sound signals the beginning of a whiskey experience I associate with Knob Creek; now gone forever.

To my point: does this change in packaging in any way influence the product inside?

11 years ago 0

masterj commented

@MyLoSyRo Packaging shouldn't influence how the product inside tastes. After all, it's just packaging. There are many decent Bourbons that come with a screw cap like the Wellers. But, as you have pointed out, it's a less formal, uncommon, way to package a spirit like Bourbon. It shouldn't affect sales, spirit quality, nor should it make Knob Creek whisky seem as if it's now a rubbish product. I think people will still buy it regardless of packaging as long as it maintains the quality of the spirit inside the bottle to a standard. However, if the spirits quality where to slide, cheap packaging could definitely exacerbate its negative image.

11 years ago 0

You must be signed-in to comment here

Sign in