OdysseusUnbound started a discussion
6 years ago
Discussions
0 12
6 years ago
Use the filters above to search this discussion.
Glenlivet 18. I'm not a huge fan of their 12 or 15, but their 18 is a step up. I prefer it to the dalwhinnie, which is just ok. To be honest, if you're a peat fan and have $130 burning a hole in your pocket I would get Lagavulin 16. It's significantly better than both.
6 years ago 1Who liked this?
@nooch Thanks for the reply. Lagavulin 16 is my absolute favourite malt ever (so far). But I keep trying new malts to broaden my palate. I'm hesitant about spending over $150 on a non-peated or a non Cask-strength whisky, but $130 seems somewhat reasonable (inasmuch as that term can ever be applied to whisky) as long as the quality is there.
6 years ago 0
Bowmore laimrig also mixes sweet and peat at a higher ABV (although I don't know if it's currently available). Glenlivet Nadurra is good too. I would get the glenlivet 18 before I'd get dalwhinnie. I'd rather get Johnny Walker Black than Dalwhinnie and save myself $40.
6 years ago 1Who liked this?
You might also try ardbeg 10 or talisker 10. Ardbeg Ugiadal (or however the heck you spell it) is good too, but way overpriced in Ontario.
6 years ago 1Who liked this?
@OdysseusUnbound, something different from the peat-forward malts you enjoy, other then Glenlivet 18 or Dalwhinnie (both of which I own and could do without), I suggest the delicious and value-packed Johnnie Walker Green Label 15 YO vatted malt. It is highly regarded by many and is currently available at LCBO for $80.
6 years ago 2Who liked this?
I have to agree with @paddockjudge. For value and quality the Green while a blended, not single malt, is probably a better choice. But if you're choosing between the livet 18 and whinnie, I would note that in my experience the latter goes "off" quickly after opening.
Bias alert, persionally I enjoy the livet 18 better.
6 years ago 1Who liked this?
@paddockjudge Thanks for the suggestion. I have nothing against blends. I spent the afternoon enjoying some Teacher's Highland Cream and marvelling at how it's possible that a scotch this good sells for only $26.
6 years ago 0
@OdysseusUnbound @paddockjudge is referring to a blended malt which is different from a blended whisky in that it is comprised of all single malts whereas a blended whisky is a blend of single malts and grain alcohol. JW Green is a blended malt (they used to be called vatted malts which was less confusing).
6 years ago 2Who liked this?
@OdysseusUnbound If you want something really different why not an Irish whisky. At 90$, Redbreast Lustau is a catch. @Talexander has wrote a nice review of it. I, for myself, find the fruits freshier in that one: more like fruit paste than dried fruits.
The JWGL would be a good choice for me too if there was not a note of varnish I dislike, but it seems I am one of the few to get it.
6 years ago 0
@BlueNote Thanks for the info. I didn't realize JW Green was a vatted malt. Interesting...
6 years ago 0
I would buy the Dalwhinnie since it is cheaper (and quite good if a little on the sweet side), and try the 'Livet 18 at a bar before you buy it. I like it but prefer the 15.
6 years ago 2Who liked this?
Thanks for all the replies and ideas, folks. But a different solution presented itself: I spent $31 on a bottle of Alberta Premium Dark Horse. Those who visit me and don't like peated whisky can have a nip of the Dark Horse or the Four Roses Single Barrel, and I can continue spending the "big bucks" (big for my whisky budget) on the peated malts I love (as suggested by @nooch)
6 years ago 1Who liked this?
First, let me say: I realize these whiskies are different.
Ok, with that out of the way, here's my situation:
The LCBO currently has Glenlivet 18 "on sale" for $130 (normally $150). Dalwhinnie 15 sells for about $95. I prefer peated whiskies, but I was thinking of grabbing one of these bottles to have something different on hand (I have a bottle of Springbank 10 at home, and I'm picking up a bottle of Laphroaig 10 very soon). I realize Dalwhinnie polarizes people, and while I've never had a whole bottle, I've had it in restaurants and pubs and I've enjoyed it. I've never tried Glenlivet 18. I'm wondering if it's worth spending the extra $35 on Glenlivet. Reviews for both are mixed (though I believe Ralfy has rated both above 90 points), so I'm just wondering what the fine folks here think. Thanks for any input.