Whisky Connosr
Shop Join

Roundstone Rye

Very Young Organic Kosher Rye

0 474

@VictorReview by @Victor

17th Feb 2011


  • Nose
  • Taste
  • Finish
  • Balance
  • Overall

Show rating data charts

Distribution of ratings for this: brand user

Catoctin Creek Distilling Company began operations in 2009 in Purcellville, Virginia. Catoctin Creek makes two 100% rye-mash whiskeys, an unaged version named Mosby's Spirit, and a very lightly aged version named Roundstone Rye, which is Mosby's Spirit aged for a very few months. The two Catoctin Creek's rye whiskeys are organic and kosher. The company does not declare whether malted rye is used for the whiskey as distinguished from the use of commercially purchased added enzymes. It was unclear on my bottle of Roundstone Rye whether the whiskey was aged 15 months or 1.5 months. Both because of the color of the whiskey, and because the only two other age references I have seen to this whiskey are 2.5 and 5 months, I believe that the sample bottle from batch # B10-RR-3 is actually aged only 1.5 months in new oak.

Nose: moderate intensity sour mash, honey, slightly floral, some rye spice, noticeable alcohol, and a hint of wood

Taste: very tart spice greeting early, alcohol tastes more than 50%, some sweet rosewater,some citrus, and some slight wood flavours of vanilla and oak

Finish: Sourness remains with considerable sweetness, similar to completely unaged spirit. The wood and spice flavours actually stay a long time, but they are quite subtle compared to other rye whiskeys

Balance: This whiskey has grown on me after repeated tastings. It is subtle rather than assertive: not a typical rye profile. As rye whiskeys go, this is a delicate flower. I think that this one can only be well appreciated if it is consumed on a fresh palate and without either food or other spirits of more assertive qualities biasing the results. You have to like that new-make sour flavour to like this one much, as well. I hope that this new distillery will in time put out a more aged rye whiskey for comparison

Related Catoctin Creek Distillers reviews


jdcook commented

It's good to have someone on the site with such an extensive experience with American whiskies who is prepared to do such in depth reviews. It's greatly appreciated, and is certainly getting me interested in a lot of the drams you have reviewed!

9 years ago 0

Victor commented

Thank you, jd! There is little that I like better than getting others interested in the drams that I enjoy!

9 years ago 0

ccy commented

great review victor. i was wondering, if this is really 15months old, is that color natural? and can you call this a rye whiskey if it's under 2yrs? and finally if you manage a bar, i was wondering if you'd consider adding this to your whiskey collection?


8 years ago 0

Victor commented

@ccy, thank you for your interest in my review. The colour of Roundstone Rye is actually quite light, and much lighter than the picture posted, above. I expect that the colour is completely natural.

As to the proper naming of the whiskey, yes, in the USA it can be called 'rye whiskey' under 2 years of barrel aging time. The 2 year aging requirement is for the word "straight" to be included with the words "rye whiskey".

The bar question is quite a good one for me, because the people who make Catoctin Creek, literally a 'mom and pop' operation, are zealous promoters of 'drinking local'. The distillery is in the outlying zone of the DC area, and their whiskey is fairly popular locally, despite being much more expensive than large-distillery brands. I personally would seldom choose Roundstone Rye as a sipper, but I do know that it is already pretty popular as a mixer around DC, Northern Virginia, and Baltimore. If I managed a bar, I'd probably pick up a bottle or two and see how it worked in some cocktails. Those bar patrons who are interested in drinking products from artisanal distillers might be well inclined to give it a try. Catoctin Creek is not exactly 'local' to New York, but it is at least regional.

If you can get your hands on Catoctin Creek's Pearousia Pear Brandy, consider giving it a try. It is outstanding, but also pricey.

8 years ago 0

You must be signed-in to comment here

Sign in