Whisky Connosr

Ballantines 17 Year Old

Sweet Young Lady

286

@mystycreekReview by @mystycreek

26th Feb 2016

0

Ballantines 17 Year Old
  • Nose
    20
  • Taste
    22
  • Finish
    21
  • Balance
    23
  • Overall
    86

Show rating data charts

Distribution of ratings for this: brand user

This bottle has been opened for over 7 months. I bought it because I wanted a whisky to drink in the summer and it was highly rated, named whisky of the year by Jim Murray. Although many people didn't agree with him on this, but since it's affordable to me, I still gave it a try. At first I was rather disappointed because it was light and watery, so I put it in the closet for a long time, but now it's all different.

Nose: Light and sweet. Lemon, citrus, fruit candy, honey, vanilla and mint. Taste: Medium body. Sweet light sherry, very Speyside, with some kick of peat in the end. Crisp at first, then become oily and spicy. Honey tea, oak, pear, and orange blossom. Finish: Warm and lingering taste of malt, honey and fruits mixed together then fade into spices, woods and smoke. Balance: Very smooth and harmonious, the sweet notes leads to the warm finish, like a symphony of Vivaldi or a painting of Claude Monet.

I can understand why many people do not appreciate this whisky. It doesn't have big flavors and it's all sweetness inside. After sipping for a while, I figure out it's a delicate and welcoming whisky, still this doesn't make an extremely high score in my mind. I find some sparks and twists of fine old whisky inside but sadly it doesn't last long, lacking some strength to go further in order to reach the promised land.

A good and finely crafted whisky overall, probably not as good as what Jim Murray said, but it's solid and easy to drink while maintaining good complexity. The new version of Ballantine's 17 years old Blended Scotch Whisky is 40% ABV, so anyone who is interested in buying a bottle had better hurry to find a 43% version before it's all gone.

Related Ballantines reviews

2 comments

@Frost
Frost commented

Great review - thank you.

After your tip off on the 43% being replaced by the 40%, I had a look in the liquor store today and discovered just that. 2 x ABV 43% on the shelf, the rest 40%. I bought a 43%, I've been putting it off for too long, and no way I'd buy the 40% to try this blend

9 months ago

@mystycreek
mystycreek commented

Yap. I'm not likely to go for the 40% version either. Normally I am a single malt guy, I will probably pick up JW Green over the new 40% version Ballantines 17 if I want a good blend.

8 months ago